Bergen County, New Jersey

Selling your home in Old Tappan.

What homes in Old Tappan actually sold for, whether a builder might pay more, and a free price estimate from an agent who works in Old Tappan.

Old Tappan Home Prices

What homes in Old Tappan sold for.

Every recorded single-family and condo sale in Old Tappan, July 2025 through June 2026, from New Jersey deed records.

60homes soldlast 12 months
$1.11Mmedian price+5.5% vs the year before
$431per sq ftolder homes, from the tax record
15bought by buildersolder homes and lots since 2019
Home sizeSoldMedian price
Under 1,500 sq ft8$788,500
1,500 to 2,500 sq ft18$944,500
2,500 to 3,500 sq ft11$1,350,000
3,500 sq ft and up23$1,733,000

Source: NJ Division of Taxation deed records (SR1A), usable sales only. Home size is from the tax record and can differ from a listing. Full Old Tappan market report.

Your Options

Two ways to sell, and you can compare both.

List it on the marketFull marketing through Corcoran Sawyer Smith and the MLS, so every buyer and agent sees it. Usually the best price for a home in good shape. Sell it to a builderBuilders bought 15 older homes and lots in Old Tappan since 2019, at a median of $600K, and the new homes on those lots sold for a median of $2.29M. If your house is older, a builder may pay as much as, or more than, a buyer who would have to renovate. Check your address free. Get both numbersWe price your home both ways, listed and as-is to a builder, side by side, so you can choose with real numbers. Nothing is shared with a builder unless you say so.

Free Estimate

What is your Old Tappan home worth?

Tell us the address. We look at the recent sales around you, your home and what builders are paying, then send you a real number.

An agent who works in Old Tappan will send your estimate, usually within one business day. No obligation.

Judy Penaherrera

Written and reviewed by

Judy Penaherrera

Licensed Realtor-Associate, NJ & FL, Builders Resource Center at Corcoran Sawyer Smith. Works with sellers in Old Tappan. Numbers updated September 2026.

About Judy ยท (201) 315-7045

Keep Exploring

More on Old Tappan.

Moving to Old TappanWhat your budget buys, how old the homes are, and what is for sale now.
Old Tappan market reportEvery home sold, median prices and the agent who knows the town.New construction in Old TappanRecent new-home sales, sizes and price per square foot.Land and teardowns in Old TappanWhat builders paid for older homes, and lots for sale now.What can you build on your lot?Enter an address: zoning, lot size and roughly how big a new home could be.