What is the average home price in New Milford, NJ?

The median sale price in New Milford was $659,600 in the 12 months through June 2026, across 106 recorded sales.

What does $750K to $1M buy in New Milford, NJ?

Homes that sold for $750K to $1M in New Milford had a median of 1,758 sq ft and were typically built around 1953, based on 25 sales in the 12 months through June 2026.

Is there new construction in New Milford, NJ?

Yes. 4 newly built homes sold in New Milford in the two years through June 2026, at a median of $1,475,000.

Bergen County, New Jersey

Moving to New Milford.

What your budget actually buys in New Milford, how old the homes are, and what is for sale right now, from state records and the MLS.

New Milford For Buyers

What your budget buys in New Milford.

Homes that sold in New Milford, July 2025 through June 2026, grouped by price. Median size and age are from the tax record.

$660Kmedian price106 sales, last 12 months

1949median year builtof homes that sold

78%built before 1960older homes sold

3%built 2019 or laternew and nearly new

Price	Homes sold	Median sq ft	Median year built
Under $750K	75	1,484	1947
$750K to $1M	25	1,758	1953
$1M to $1.5M	3	2,908	2012
$1.5M to $2M	3	4,115	2006

Source: NJ Division of Taxation deed records (SR1A), usable single-family and condo sales. Medians need at least three sales.

Homes for Sale

Search every home for sale in New Milford.

Live from the MLS and updated all day.

Work With Us

Looking in New Milford? Tell us what you need.

An agent who works in this town will send you homes that fit, including new construction and homes that are not widely advertised yet.

Written and reviewed by

Judy Penaherrera

Licensed Realtor-Associate, NJ & FL, Builders Resource Center at Corcoran Sawyer Smith. Helps buyers find homes in New Milford. Numbers updated September 2026.

About Judy · (201) 315-7045

Keep Exploring

More on New Milford.

Selling a home in New MilfordWhat homes sold for, what a builder might pay, and a free price estimate.New Milford zoning for buildersLot sizes, setbacks and how big a new house can be, zone by zone.

New Milford market reportEvery home sold, median prices and the agent who knows the town.What can you build on your lot?Enter an address: zoning, lot size and roughly how big a new home could be.